History of tax morality

To the project database

The "Suisse Secrets" show just as much as the "Paradise" and the "Panama Papers": dishonest tax payments are increasingly being perceived as a problem and scandalised in the public consciousness. After all, taxes could help to distribute the costs of the current coronavirus, Ukraine and climate crises more or less fairly across society and prevent a further widening of the social gap - if everyone paid their taxes, if tax morale wasn't so bad.

 

Tax mor­ale - what is it ac­tu­ally?

In the project, tax morality is understood as the norms of tax payment, which aim to prevent deviant behaviour by individuals and which must be constantly renegotiated. Accordingly, the project examines the discourses surrounding honest tax payment between the Second World War and the 1980s, specifically in the three sample countries of West Germany, Spain and the USA. Who expressed their views on the subject and how, and what interests did those involved pursue? How were the norms of taxpaying, i.e. tax morality, repeatedly renegotiated? What narratives of taxpaying developed under very different economic, political and cultural conditions? What determined whether a narrative could prevail in the public debate that explained tax evasion or avoidance as self-defence of the citizen against completely excessive state demands - or one that portrayed tax evaders as criminals who endangered the greater good?

What sources are avail­able for a his­tory of tax mor­al­ity?

Answers to the historian's questions can be found in a wide variety of source genres, from newspaper articles to television discussion panels, from the statement of a church representative to a party programme, from an economic model to a lecture by a lobby representative, from teaching material on tax education to a tax guidebook. How did the norms of tax payment develop in public discourse in the early Federal Republic of Germany, in Spain under Franco and after the transition to democracy, and in the USA during the Cold War? A historical understanding of the development is indispensable for analysing current challenges in the field of tax morality.

 

The project is sponsored by the DFG as part of the Heisenberg Programme from 2018-2025.

Pro­ject man­age­ment

business-card image

Prof. Dr. Korinna Schönhärl

Modern and Contemporary History

Professor for Modern History

Write email +49 5251 60-2436

Team

Mariana Ariza Hernandez

More about the person

Victoria Winterfeld

Modern and Contemporary History

More about the person

Pub­lic­a­tions

Korinna Schönhärl, Nasrin Düll, and Nadya Melina Ramírez Lugo

Tax Education After WWII: How Spain, the USA, and West Germany Tried to Make Their Citizens Pay Honestly, in: Tax Evasion and Tax Havens since the Nineteenth Century, ed. Sébastien Guex and Hadrien Buclin, Cham 2023, pp. 355-376, open access.

To the article

Korinna Schönhärl

Tax Morale and the Church: How Catholic Clergies Adapted Norms of Paying Taxes to Secular Institutions (1940s-1950s), in: Lutz, Martin; Skambraks, Tanja: Reassassing the Moral Economy: Religion and Economic Ethics from Ancient Greece to the 20th Century, Graz 2023, pp. 237 - 258.

To the article

Korinna Schönhärl, Nasrin Düll, Nadya Melina Ramírez Lugo

Tax Education After WWII: How Spain, the USA, and West Germany Tried to Make Their Citizens Pay Honestly, in: Tax Evasion and Tax Havens since the Nineteenth Century, ed. Sébastien Guex and Hadrien Buclin, Cham 2023, pp. 355-376

To the article

Korinna Schönhärl, Gisela Hürlimann, Dorothea Rohde

Histories of Tax Evasion, Avoidance and Resistance, London 2022. The book is published Open Access and can be downloaded for free!

About the book

Korinna Schönhärl

National Report: Germany, in: Peter Esser (Ed.): History and Taxation. The Dialectic Relationship between Taxation and Political Balance in Power (EATLP International Tax Series 20), Amsterdam 2022, pp. 303-326.

To the article

Korinna Schönhärl

Review: Steinmo, Sven, Willing to Pay? A Reasonable Choice Approach. Oxford 2021. in: HSozKult, 23.06.2022.

To the review

Marc Buggeln, Korinna Schönhärl

The cost of saving Europe: debt and tax cultures in historical perspective, in: HSozKult, 26 August 2020.

To the article

Activities

18.04.2024

Vor­trag auf der Ta­gung "The Struggle to tax in­her­it­ance An im­possible de­bate?"

Read more
19.01.2024

Vor­trag beim In­ter­na­tion­al Work­shop "Glob­al Tax Chains: Act­ors and prac­tices of glob­al cap­it­al­ism in the second of the half of the 20th…

Read more
05.10.2023

Ab­schlusskom­ment­ar auf der Ta­gung "Reich wer­den - und bleiben?! Strategi­en nach­halti­gen In­vest­ier­ens in epochen- und…

Read more
29.09.2023

Vor­trag auf dem in­ter­na­tionalen Kon­gress "Polit­ische The­or­ie in Zeiten der Un­gewis­sheit" an der Uni­versität Bre­men

Read more
10.07.2023

Ex­plor­at­ory Work­shop im Bildungs­for­um Pots­dam

Read more
01.02.2023

Vor­trag im Rah­men des Forschungssem­inars "Wirtschafts- und Sozi­al­geschichte", Uni­versität Re­gens­burg

Read more
29.11.2022

GWU Kolloqui­um, Uni­versität Biele­feld

Read more
More news

Press

14.06.2024

Kon­fer­en­zbericht zur Ta­gung "God, Taxes and So­ci­et­ies" auf HSozKult

Read more
06.06.2024

Korinna Schön­härl im His­tory-Talk bei Deutsch­land­funk

Read more
06.05.2024

Korinna Schön­härl im Ge­spräch beim Landes­mu­seum Zürich

Read more
19.04.2024

Korinna Schön­härl im ös­ter­reichis­chen "Stand­ard"

Read more
18.12.2023

Korinna Schön­härl im Ge­spräch bei Ter­raX auf Spo­ti­fy: Die Geschichte der Steuern

Read more
08.12.2023

Korinna Schön­härl im In­ter­view beim SWR: Leben mit Pol­ster – Lohnt es sich zu spar­en?

Read more
30.01.2022

Korinna Schön­härl im Ge­spräch mit Deutsch­land­funk

Read more
More news